
The other day I discovered this little Quora doozy: https://deepthoughts.quora.com/Screenshot-which-de...
Oh wow. That is one hell of a concept-art image.
We all hear tales of hilarious culture clashes between architects and civil engineers, don’t we. Apparently architects earn this reputation for empty-headed daydreaming. So many architects, apparently, conjure up baffling dreams of structural grandeur. They involve structures radiant with impossible grace and beauty and zero practicality whatsoever.
Civil engineers then grumpily point out the ten thousand ways that the architects’ dreams are physically impossible. The architects' glorious ambitions would explode horribly the instant anyone attempts to build it, or even burp on the blueprints.
The architects then accuse the civil engineers of being miserable killjoys. And the circle of designer-vs-developer life continues forever.
I must admit I've got a soft spot for architects enjoying themselves. But come on. This time I'll have to side with the engineers.
Just look at this damn image! Above and beyond anything else, this Sky Hotel's landing gear is down. It’s apparently flying at high altitude. But the friggin’ landing gear is fully extended. Is it attempting a landing on the summit pointy-bit of Mt. Everest? Or upon one of those ridiculous hovering super-carriers, just out of shot, that you get in the sillier types of science fiction?
The Sky Hotel also possesses about a gazillion just engines. This looks like the kind of hilarious bullshit I’d happily cobble together in Kerbal Space Program. Don’t get me wrong, I’m all for the championing and propagation of hilarious bullshit, if, IF, everyone is already upfront and properly informed that this is in fact what’s happening. Then it's a ton of fun. IF.
The problem is, so often, these images’ authors actually believe their own bullshit. They actually convince themselves that crap like this might realistically take off, in both senses. Take it from me, harsh Kerbal Space Program experience has taught me that monstrosities like this seldom even survive to the other end of the runway without exploding horribly and all crew perishing. Same here.
One commenter mused on how the hell you'd ever heat the damn thing. Look at those huge windows! You'd freeze! But it got me wondering. Isn’t there some kind of airspeed threshold, whereby if you exceed it, this phenomenon actually reverses, and the plane starts heating up? I think it’s around Mach 2.5.
Don’t get me wrong, I’ll be the first to acknowledge that the obvious retort to my claim is “oh give me a break, there’s no way in hell that tourist crate would ever go supersonic, let alone >M2.5”, and yup I 100% agree … but … just look at that friggin’ concept-art image. How likely is it that its creator knows about supersonic flight, its physics, and its limitations?
Chances are, if they’ve given anything more than zero thought to airspeed, that thought would be something like:
“Ooooohyeah we should totally make it go at Mach 10 or something! Yeah! Make it happen — I’m getting sick of you questioning me! I’m the ideas guy, you’re the details guy, get on it! Wait come back! ... Oh for God’s sake, yet another engineer just quit on me, another couldn’t hack it, God, why is everyone but me such a LOSER? Okay, it's obvious that aerospace engineers are a bunch of weak-willed softcocks! I'm abandoning all you LOSERS and pivoting to submersibles! I shall call my new company OCEANGATE.”